As mentioned on Friday, the Land Use and Development Committee for the City and County of San Francisco is holding a hearing on Monday, January 24, 2011 to discuss the proposed Existing Commercial Buildings Energy Performance Ordinance. I encourage you to attend if possible.
The proposed ordinance would require certain commercial buildings to produce two reports, (1) an energy and performance audit every five years and (2) an Annual Energy Benchmark Summary (AEBS). Save for any confidential information, the audit and the AEBS would be made available to the public. The ordinance makes sense, but may place a cost on building owners that will inevitably be passed on to renters. The upside is that renters usually pay for utilities, so energy savings may offset the cost of the audit…something to think about in a green lease, that’s for sure.
Here’s a short summary:
The proposed ordinance will require two reports. The first report is the AEBS, and that will use the Energy Star Portfolio Manager Energy Performance Rating as a basis. This report will likely not cost too much money as it is based on the Portfolio Manager software that is freely available, and the data is generated from the local utility (in the case of San Francisco, PG&E).
The second report is a building-wide audit (as defined by ASHRAE Procedures for Commercial Building Energy Audits) conducted by a third-party vendor. As such, I am guessing the audit likely carries a higher price tag. Full disclosure, I have never hired someone to do an energy audit for a commercial building, so I am only guessing that the fees are more than nominal.
After the initial three-year staggered start period (which will also be used for the AEBS), the required energy audit would be required once every five years. As proposed, the audit requirement is as follows: Level I audits (as defined by ASHRAE) are essentially “walk-through” audits. These are required for buildings between 10,000 to 49,999 sq ft (smaller buildings). Level II audits (as defined by ASHRAE) are comprehensive surveys and analyses, and they are required for all buildings 50,000 sq ft and above. (larger buildings).
If owners do not comply with the requirements they may face fines. The fines are $100/day (for larger buildings) or $50/day (for smaller buildings) for every day of non-compliance up to 25 days per 12 month period. In other words, the maximum fine per year is $2,500 for a large building and $1,250 for a small building.
In general I like the ordinance but there are some issues that should be addressed… (more…)
Steve Sacks
